Popup Image

Share this powerful gallery of art and climate.

These paintings speak of survival, resistance, and care. Share this page with those who value community, creativity, and climate justice.

Back

State Climate Action

Tamil Nadu

Makkal Arangam: When Listening Becomes Part of Governing

Sanjiv Gopal

16 November 2026

Public participation can be more than a way to raise concerns. It can help governments spot problems that routine systems miss and connect people’s everyday experiences with public decisions.

Imagine residents repeatedly raising concerns about the same streets flooding every monsoon, cutting off access to a school or hospital. Or farmers struggling with changing rainfall patterns and finding that the support they need sits across several departments. Or residents near a polluted waterbody trying to get different government departments to respond. Problems like these may not be new and climate change will make some of these pressures more frequent and severe. And responses can fall between the cracks, with each department seeing only part of the picture. 

This is where a commitment in the Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam’s (TVK) election manifesto opens an interesting opportunity. Its Makkal Arangam idea (People’s Assembly) would allow citizens to submit petitions directly to the Legislative Assembly. According to the party’s website, petitions with 10,000 signatures would require a government response, while those receiving 500,000 signatures would be taken up for discussion in the Assembly. It also proposes setting aside a day in each Assembly session for public petitions.  They now lead Tamil Nadu’s coalition government and have a clear opportunity to take the idea forward.

Insights from elsewhere

Petitions themselves are not new. India’s Parliament has committees on petitions in both the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha. Some state legislatures have similar mechanisms. For instance, the Kerala Legislative Assembly’s Committee on Petitions examines complaints and can recommend remedial measures. What is distinctive about Makkal Arangam is the proposed combination of direct access to the Assembly, signature thresholds linked to a government response or legislative discussion, and a dedicated day for public petitions. I am not aware of a directly comparable mechanism across India combining all three. While the details will matter, the idea offers a way to make the route from public concern to legislative attention more visible.

Other systems offer useful insights. In the United Kingdom, petitions reaching 10,000 signatures receive a government response, while those reaching 100,000 are considered for parliamentary debate, though debate is not guaranteed. The European Parliament’s petitions process has led to legislative or political action on some issues, including environmental concerns. Taiwan’s government-run Join platform lets people propose ideas, discuss policies under development and provide feedback on government programs.

These models differ but share an important principle: the path between raising a concern and an institution responding to it can be designed. A system can simply collect grievances or help governments recognise patterns, ask better questions and decide what needs closer attention. It can also make clear what collective support triggers and what happens next.

Beyond the grievance: public response as a source of intelligence

The opportunity extends beyond petitions. Government departments have their own mandates, budgets, targets and reporting systems. These are necessary but can obscure how people experience a problem across departmental boundaries. Consider extreme heat. Its effects show up as health problems, lost working hours, pressure on drinking water and unsafe conditions for people working outdoors. These effects may be recorded separately. Taken together, they could show how the issues connect and where one department’s response needs support from another.

Public concerns do not diagnose problems on their own. But they can signal where to look more closely, what questions to ask and which departments may need to work together. This intelligence can complement administrative data, research, inspections and feedback from local bodies, confirming what they show or pointing to what they miss. The value is not simply another channel for grievances. It is a way to identify gaps in the government’s understanding of a problem. When these affect how public resources are allocated, the consequence can be fiscal as well as administrative.

This will not automatically save money or make spending more efficient as that depends on how governments use the information. Public concerns may reveal where recurring problems add up or where an investment is not addressing what people experience. A local infrastructure project, for instance, may meet its delivery target while leaving the underlying problem unresolved.

The point is also not about making the most popular demand the next budget priority. Signature counts alone cannot show how serious a problem is, who is affected or which response will work. Their value is in helping the government ask better questions, check whether investments are working and identify where a coordinated response may be needed. For all governments that must manage competing demands, priorities and resources, that is worth exploring.

Making it work

The digital platform is only one part of the task. The harder work is building a credible process around it.

  • First, access must extend beyond digital reach. People should be able to raise concerns in Tamil and accessible formats, with offline options for those unable to use an online platform. The system should also identify whose voices are missing; otherwise, the already organised may be heard more easily than those facing serious but less visible problems.
  • Second, the response must go beyond acknowledgement. People should see which department is responsible, what evidence was considered, what action is possible and, if no action is planned, why. Clear timelines and public responses would make the process trackable.
  • For climate-related concerns, this could also mean explaining whether and how relevant petitions are considered alongside existing state climate-planning processes, including the Tamil Nadu Climate Change Mission and the State Action Plan on Climate Change.
  • Third, legislative discussion should lead somewhere. A concern need not lead to a policy change; it could prompt further evidence, an investigation or a reasoned decision not to act. People should be able to see how it was considered and what happened next.
  • Finally, signature counts must inform judgement, not replace it. Those most affected by climate risks such as heat, flooding and sea-level rise may have urgent concerns but limited capacity to mobilise 10,000 signatures. This may include residents of informal settlements, daily-wage workers and coastal communities, whose concerns should not be overlooked simply because they attract fewer signatures

An opportunity for Tamil Nadu

Makkal Arangam was a commitment in TVK’s election manifesto. Taking it forward could create an innovation in public administration, connecting what people experience with how the government sets priorities, coordinates its work and accounts for its decisions. Its relevance extends across transport, water, heat, livelihoods, education, health, the environment, public services and more. These problems are often experienced locally, while their causes and solutions often cut across departments and levels of government.

The opportunity now is to work through implementation and demonstrate what it achieves in practice. The test begins after a concern is raised. Does the government notice what it missed, ask a better question, bring the right people together, make a more informed decision and show the public what happened next?

If an idea like Makkal Arangam can create that connection, it could offer a useful model for other states too, especially as they adapt to a changing climate. The larger opportunity is to make listening a part of how the government understands problems, decides and acts and not just a way for people to be heard.

Receive Insights That Matter

Be the first to hear about new initiatives, community voices, and grounded climate solutions.